Fee Download Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson
We will reveal you the very best as well as most convenient way to get book Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson in this globe. Bunches of collections that will certainly assist your obligation will be here. It will certainly make you feel so best to be part of this internet site. Becoming the member to constantly see what up-to-date from this publication Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson site will make you feel ideal to look for guides. So, just now, and also here, get this Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson to download and also save it for your priceless worthwhile.
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson
Fee Download Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson. Satisfied reading! This is exactly what we wish to state to you which enjoy reading so much. What regarding you that declare that reading are only commitment? Don't bother, reviewing practice should be begun with some particular reasons. Among them is reading by commitment. As what we really want to offer below, the book entitled Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson is not sort of required book. You can appreciate this e-book Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson to check out.
If you ally require such a referred Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson book that will certainly offer you value, obtain the best seller from us currently from numerous prominent publishers. If you want to entertaining books, numerous books, story, jokes, and much more fictions collections are also released, from best seller to one of the most current launched. You could not be puzzled to delight in all book collections Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson that we will offer. It is not concerning the costs. It has to do with just what you require now. This Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson, as one of the best sellers here will certainly be one of the right selections to review.
Finding the appropriate Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson publication as the right need is type of lucks to have. To begin your day or to finish your day during the night, this Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson will be proper sufficient. You can just hunt for the tile right here and also you will get the book Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson referred. It will certainly not trouble you to reduce your important time to go with shopping publication in store. This way, you will additionally invest money to pay for transportation and also various other time spent.
By downloading and install the online Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson book right here, you will obtain some benefits not to go with guide establishment. Just hook up to the net and begin to download and install the page web link we share. Currently, your Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson is ready to delight in reading. This is your time and also your serenity to get all that you desire from this publication Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, And The Nature Of Society, By David Sloan Wilson
One of the great intellectual battles of modern times is between evolution and religion. Until now, they have been considered completely irreconcilable theories of origin and existence. David Sloan Wilson's Darwin's Cathedral takes the radical step of joining the two, in the process proposing an evolutionary theory of religion that shakes both evolutionary biology and social theory at their foundations.
The key, argues Wilson, is to think of society as an organism, an old idea that has received new life based on recent developments in evolutionary biology. If society is an organism, can we then think of morality and religion as biologically and culturally evolved adaptations that enable human groups to function as single units rather than mere collections of individuals? Wilson brings a variety of evidence to bear on this question, from both the biological and social sciences. From Calvinism in sixteenth-century Geneva to Balinese water temples, from hunter-gatherer societies to urban America, Wilson demonstrates how religions have enabled people to achieve by collective action what they never could do alone. He also includes a chapter considering forgiveness from an evolutionary perspective and concludes by discussing how all social organizations, including science, could benefit by incorporating elements of religion.
Religious believers often compare their communities to single organisms and even to insect colonies. Astoundingly, Wilson shows that they might be literally correct. Intended for any educated reader, Darwin's Cathedral will change forever the way we view the relations among evolution, religion, and human society.
- Sales Rank: #355597 in Books
- Published on: 2003-10-01
- Released on: 2002-06-01
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.00" h x .90" w x 6.00" l, .83 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 268 pages
Amazon.com Review
God or evolution? Though the debate about our origins has swirled in epic controversy since Darwin's time, David Sloan Wilson bravely blends these two contentious theories. This has been tried before, of course, mainly by religious intellectuals. What makes Darwin's Cathedral stand out is that Wilson does not pursue the classic "intelligent design" argument (evolution is God's hand at work), but instead argues that religion is evolution at work.
Wilson sees religion as a complex organism with "biological" functions. He argues that the social cohesiveness of religion makes it analogous to a beehive or a human body--and, in fact, religious believers sometimes employ these metaphors. He writes, "Thinking of a religious group as like an organism encourages us to look for adaptive complexity.... Mechanisms are required that are often awesome in their sophistication." To Wilson, therein lies the astonishing complexity of religion, just as in the biological world.
Following Wilson's argument requires understanding the rudiments of evolutionary biology; a smattering of theology, history, anthropology, sociology, and psychology is helpful, too. But the reasoning isn't as challenging as Wilson warns in the introduction. For educated readers, it's an accessible book.
In just 260 pages, Wilson can't begin to do justice to the broad swath of intellectual work he's cut out for himself. And ultimately, the book's main failing is its simplicity. In addition, his approach to religion is so clearly an outsider's that he is unlikely to win many converts. Adaptive-mechanistic explanations of forgiveness and altruism may be intriguing to the atheist in the ivory tower, but they are likely to elicit little more than a bemused and passing interest from believers. --Eric de Place
From Library Journal
Viewing religion from an evolutionary perspective, Wilson (biology and anthropology, Binghamton Univ.) argues that religious belief and other symbolic systems are closely connected to reality in that they are a powerful force in motivating adaptive behaviors. Disconnecting religion from its reliance on supernatural agents as a defining principle, he posits human religious groups as adaptive organisms wherein processes like group selection, evolutionary pressures, and moral systems come into play, offering a new avenue for interpretive insights. To his credit, Wilson looks for a middle ground in this complex confluence of biology, sociology, anthropology, and religion: "I think group selection can explain much about religion but by no means all." He depends heavily on Darwinian theory, sociologists like Rodney Stark, and symbolic thinkers like Emile Durkheim and Terrence Deacon. He ultimately argues for the power of symbolic thinking as a sophisticated adaptive advantage alongside factual thinking. Wilson's readers should be prepared for a tightly argued, highly academic yet satisfying read. Sandra Collins, Duquesne Univ. Lib., Pittsburgh
Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
Review
"Darwin's Cathedral is a masterpiece of clear thinking and even clearer writing. It is such a joy to read an important original contribution to science such as Wilson makes here, that can be read and valued by both professional and general readers. Darwin's Cathedral will go down as one of the classic treatises on the study of religion, alongside those produced by William James, Emile Durkheim, and Sigmund Freud, only Wilson's thesis has the added advantage of being scientifically testable." - Michael Shermer, author of How We Believe, Editor-in-Chief of Skeptic magazine, columnist for Scientific American
Most helpful customer reviews
121 of 130 people found the following review helpful.
Durkheim's Revenge (?)
By Todd I. Stark
It has become inescapable to see ourselves as having evolved for group living. In "Origins of Virtue," Matt Ridley described the overall situation admirably well, and concluded that selfish organisms can evolve mechanisms that exploit the advantages of living together in groups, so long as those mechanisms don't sacrifice too much for the individual. The great fountain of selfish gene imagery, Richard Dawkins, once wrote that Ridley's book could well serve as a followup to "The Selfish Gene" as applied to human beings. So there is little doubt that even a theory based on "selfish genes" can be seen as explaining behavior that takes advantage of living in groups.
David Sloane Wilson first acknowledges that traits which promote us to sacrifice ourselves "for the good of the group" are unlikely to spread in a population. He find great value in fields like evolutionary psychology for finding innate human psychological traits that promote individual reproduction and survival. However, he also takes a thought provoking look at important transitions in evolutionary history and finds that under certain special conditions, individuals become united and begin to function in a very real sense as a larger organism. Genes become united into chromosomes, cells become organisms, organisms become hives.
None of this is new so far of course. What is unique is the claim that some of these transitions cannot be explained without having some form of competition between groups whose traits are widely divergent. The basic problem is that behavior that allows one group to fare better than another must also allow the individuals to survive and reproduce within their own group. So self-sacrificing behavior that makes a group of berzerkers unbeatable in battle against other groups has a hard time taking root _within_ the group of berzerkers unless it also serves them there. Wilson claims that the bias against seeing selection occurrring at multiple levels, especially by the way genetic fitness calculations are averaged, prevents most biologists from seeing "group selection" when it does occur. He then proposes that the missing piece is human moral systems themselves, which provide mechanisms that lower the cost of behavior "for the group" in terms of individual fitness.
For example, social controls such as rewards and punishments are known to strongly foster cooperation even though cooperation is very fragile otherwise. We have tended to see this either in terms of individual self-determination or entirely in terms of social pressure. Wilson's view allows a middle ground, of innate traits which social controls can leverage powerfully to produce cooperation. Wilson's main point is that such traits probably require a multi-level selection theory to explain.
Wilson uses scholarly study of religion from a variety of fields to illustrate how human behavior shows evidence of forming groups as adaptive units in the evolutionary sense. This was an idea that was proposed by Darwin (thus "Darwin's Cathedral") and seen as fundamental by many social scientists, but was roundly rejected for the difficulties it brings into population models of evolution. In addition, the recent critiques often brought to bear on social science sometimes tend to see social science concepts such as those of Emile Durkheim as something needing to be slashed and burned rather than just seen in a new light. Wilson takes a new look at Durkheim's functionalist view of society and the various critiques of it, and finds plenty of archaic ideas, but also notes that the central theme of religion serving to unify human groups remains out of the ashes.
In Darwin's Cathedral, Wilson compares his view of religion as something that unifies human groups with the competing views of religion as a collection of arbitrary Gouldian "spandrels" or byproducts of evolution, the view that religion is a form of catchy imagination, and the Dawkinsian view that religious beliefs are mental parasites, and makes his case very well. He is very careful in his analysis and pulls from a wide range of scholarly material to make his case that, provided we are very careful about how we measure Darwinian fitness and very careful not to look for group selection where behavior can be explained otherwise, we can explain aspects of human behavior that simply can't be explained in terms of inclusive fitness for the genes of our relatives or even by playing games of reciprocal altruism.
Wilson makes many of the same points as Pascal Boyer does in "Religion Explained," but seems to tie things together more neatly with his theoretical framework. Since he is not limiting himself to psychological adaptations that solely promote individual survival and reproduction, Wilson has the added flexibility to pose adaptations for punishment and reward that serve social ends, which makes for much more elegant and powerful theory that explains a wider range of phenomena such as the tendency of human beings to see themselves readily as members of groups, their willingness to punish defectors, the the joy most of us get out of finding that we've helped someone else.
The only problem with this book is that Wilson takes on too much of a task here for one slim volume. The data on human religion is massive. I'm reminded of Frazer's classic "Golden Bough" and how virtually no one has ever actually read it all the way through in its single highly condensed volume, much less the dozen or so volumes he originally wrote. And yet he makes his point. Wilson also makes his point, and then draws from the massive data but seems to suffer in trying to navigate it all. He spends a lot of time looking at Calvinism from various angles for example. Everything he reviews seems to help him support his theory of religion as adaptive and unifying, but there is so much more to look at that in the end it feels oddly incomplete.
This is wonderful interdisciplinary theoretical work that deserves much more followup than a single person can possibly give it.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Five Stars
By racerep
Excellent
14 of 18 people found the following review helpful.
Visiting Darwins Cathedral
By A Customer
I found this to be an extraordinary book....Dr. Wilson combines impeccable science in his own field with a widespread interest and respect for scientific fields other than his own and has the unique ability to synthesise their offerings into his own understanding and ongoing inquiries. The author has an obvious and contagious relish for ideas, and unlike many authors has not attempted to write "gospel" but has hoped to start, and even explicitly invited dialoque. What makes Dr. Wilsons book additionally unique, is not only the depth and breadth of his ideas and research but his unique style of writting. Rarely is immaculate and lucid scientific discourse, great humor, and poetic expression found in one volume, as is the case here. The book from conception to execution is a thought provoking delight, whatever preconceptions regarding evolution or religion you bring to it's pages. You do not have to be a scientist to enjoy this book, only a person who enjoys the challanges of good ideas masterfully presented
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson PDF
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson EPub
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson Doc
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson iBooks
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson rtf
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson Mobipocket
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion, and the Nature of Society, by David Sloan Wilson Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar